So, who’s going to resurrect the electric car?
The natural followup to Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth is, of course, a documentary about alternative energy transportation, being that Truth is essentially an indictment of the world’s dependency on fossil fuel (and the primary cause for this nation’s oil addiction is, of course, cars). Enter Who Killed the Electric Car, a scathing exposé on the untimely (and unsurprising) death of the electric vehicle initiative at GM (and to a lesser extent, Toyota, Honda, etc.).
Not unlike Truth, it’s my opinion that this film should be seen by anyone who uses fossil fuels directly (or indirectly) — basically everyone who lives in this country, anyone who drives, participates in transportation. But this post isn’t about why you should see the movie, it’s to ask why technologists haven’t stepped up to the plate to create an electric car company.
It’s obvious that electric cars aren’t coming back. The government and the auto industry are too heavily invested in fuel cell technology, which Jimmy Carter’s former energy advisor S. David Freeman likens to a dog race chasing the white rabbit they’ll never catch. Fuel cells are forever 10-15 years away, and even if they finally make it to market in 2015, guess what, it’s too late. The compromise: hybrid vehicles, that get significantly better mileage, but that still use gas. Sipping — not guzzling — doesn’t mean we’re no longer drinking Middle Eastern oil, or putting global warming gasses into the atmosphere.
What we need in the US is a true, competitive all-EV car company. The technology is cheap, available, and ready to deploy; there are already numerous European (even American) EV car manufacturers. What is the US market so afraid of? All we need are some leaders to stand behind the initiative and bring forth some product designed to appeal to the US market, manufactured by a company that operates outside the influence of the oil industry.
Would it be so unheardof if a wealthy technology visionary (say, Marc Cuban) got together with, say, a green-oriented politician who’s fought the auto industry his entire professional career (like, say, Ralph Nader), and perhaps the one man most suited in this country to fight the powers that would surely try to shut such a concerted effort down (Al Gore)? Maybe that kind of triumvirate is a little silly sounding, but the idea of a green car company absolutely is not. Do you think these people could raise enough money to start a car company? Would you buy such a car? Why not?
Inventor and creator of the NiMH battery that powered the original GM EV1 fleet, Stan Ovshinsky, hit the nail on the head: it’s our obligation to use technology to better mankind, and as such, our world. We’d be foolish to invest thousands of dollars a year, each and everyone one of us, on a solution that finds us deteriorating our atmosphere, causing global air-related health issues, and possibly most prevalently, warring in foreign nations securing oil. So, how’s going to resurrect the electric car?
Co-founder of


The google and paypal founders are.
http://www.buffalonews.com/editorial/20060717/1036571.asp
The problem I had with who killed the electric car was that it was missing the thing that made gore’s movie so great — mass appeal. Gore’s movie was written in a way, that irregardless of politics, would settle in.
Electric car, not so much. It appeals to people who go see indie movies — the exact people who don’t need to be convinced of change. Too much subjective (some would say revisionist) politics, when there wasn’t any need for it. The case for the electric car stands on its own merit.
I saw Tesla, and I\’ve seen Wrightspeed. Unfortunately right these guys are out to prove something — that electrics can outperform gas powered cars. Sure, great, wonderful, but is all of the US going buy a Tesla racer for a few hundred grand? No. Give us a regular, safe, decent electric car, and stop showing off — right? These are just not mass market vehicles, and that\’s what we need to kick oil.
I def agree with your assessment of the film, though. While it\’s provocative, it doesn\’t provide any real imperative. It\’s definitely more depressing than actionable, which is why I want to see someone step up and build a company around this concept instead of moaning about what GM does/doesn\’t do with EVs.
[...] Yesterday Ryan got me to see “Who Killed the Electric Car?” It’s an interesting documentary about the demise of cars like the EV1, and other vehicles which were promising consumers of a way to commute without contributing to the greenhouse effect. Ryan wrote a great entryover on his blog about bringing back the electric car. If you’re interested, go check it out and join in on the discussion. [...]
I heard the Tesla is only the first phase. If they can get enough sold, they’re coming out with a family car next.